St. Mark's United Church

 

We are called to be

a progressive, inclusive life-affirming

Christian community of faith within

The United Church of Canada

 

The Secret

Author: Rhonda Byrne

 Reviewer: Katharina Manassis

 

    The Secret

 

             Since being touted by Oprah Winfrey as the book that changed her life, “The Secret” has been flying off the shelves of bookstores across North America. I bought a copy last summer to see what all the fuss was about.

            What I found was an interesting collection of quotes and short writings from American self-help gurus and famous people throughout the ages which contain some common ideas.  These common ideas, referred to by the author as “the secret”, emerge slowly over the course of the book, keeping the reader turning the pages with anticipation. From Emerson to Einstein, luminaries in every field are said to have grasped and lived according to “the secret”.

            What is this secret?  In a nutshell, the idea is that you should regularly envision what you want, avoid envisioning what you don’t want, and assume that what you want will be provided eventually.  For example, if you want to eliminate poverty, you should not imagine eliminating poverty. Instead, you should imagine creating prosperity.  If you want to get a parking spot at the mall, imagine seeing it and assume it will be there waiting for you. 

This makes sense to me.  After all, focusing on what you want creates a sense of optimism, which is energizing, and makes it more likely you will actually achieve your goal.  Similarly, assuming that good things will come your way is reassuring, allowing you to become more relaxed and friendly.  People tend to be nice to you when you relate to them in a relaxed and friendly way, making it more likely that good things will indeed come your way. These are logical, self-fulfilling prophecies.

Unfortunately, “The Secret” takes this approach one step further, and here’s where it gets a little strange.  Byrne and those she quotes claim that by imagining what you want and assuming it will happen, you somehow influence the universe (or Universe, depending on one’s beliefs) to send it your way.  In other words, “believe something good will happen, and it will”.  I wonder what Holocaust survivors or people suffering from terminal illnesses would say to that.  Did their misfortune happen because they did not believe in “the secret”?  It is unimaginably cruel to even suggest that.  Is also seems a little superstitious.  A lot of awful things are simply beyond our control, no matter how many rosy alternative scenarios we envision.

In summary, although some of the ideas in this book may be helpful, one does need to read “The Secret” with a healthy skepticism.  The parking spot trick seems to work, though.  Try it!

© St. Mark's United Church     115 Orton Park Road     Scarborough, ON    Canada     M1G 3G9  

For questions, comments, or permission to reprint material on this site please email: webadmin@st-marks.ca